shunji (angryzenmaster) wrote,
shunji
angryzenmaster

Immersion is a stupid word.

Every time I hear another game developer talk about "immersion" I want to vomit. Many horrible game decisions have been made in the name of "immersion." Things like un-interruptive cutscenes, slow and unresponsive UI, annoying player character chatter, Game Over screens, etc.

I think if you really want immersion, you should ask the players, "What made the game inconsistent for you?" People are extremely good at using the same control mechanism to experience things; we use keyboards and typing to chat over the internet much in the same we we try to converse in real life. We are masters of experience through abstraction. No one argues that the written word is an outmoded form of expression or experience communication, yet there is a certain level of arrogance amongst developers that we need "innovation" in control schemes to make more immersive games. I would rather that games just be more fun to play with existing controllers.

No point, just ire.
Subscribe

  • "It's a ceremony!" "It's psychotic!"

    One potentially fun aspect of GDC is how easy it can be to get into arguments between those who know what they are talking about and those who think…

  • Two week update

    By now, I'm sure you have all heard about the new content we (Bungie) are releasing as both DLC on XBL and as a separate DVD. I'm not going to step…

  • Because... you listen

    Thoughts that I've had over the past three months: 1. Is there a mechanism that can replace raw ability and talent with education? 2. If a poorly…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 17 comments

  • "It's a ceremony!" "It's psychotic!"

    One potentially fun aspect of GDC is how easy it can be to get into arguments between those who know what they are talking about and those who think…

  • Two week update

    By now, I'm sure you have all heard about the new content we (Bungie) are releasing as both DLC on XBL and as a separate DVD. I'm not going to step…

  • Because... you listen

    Thoughts that I've had over the past three months: 1. Is there a mechanism that can replace raw ability and talent with education? 2. If a poorly…